On Iran, Bush faces questions of what he knew when

WASHINGTON Wed Dec 5, 2007 4:12am GMT

Related Topics

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President George W. Bush faced questions on Tuesday about whether he knew of intelligence that Iran had ended its nuclear arms program when he warned in October that Tehran could trigger World War Three.

"Can't you be accused of hyping this threat?" Bush was asked at a news conference a day after his administration released a new National Intelligence Estimate concluding that Iran halted its nuclear weapons program in 2003.

"I was made aware of the NIE last week," Bush replied.

But it was his next remark that drew attention from Democrats, the news media and intelligence experts: "In August, I think it was (U.S. intelligence chief) Mike McConnell came in and said, 'We have some new information.' He didn't tell me what the information was."

Increasingly strident U.S. rhetoric over Iran's nuclear program reached a peak on October 17 when Bush warned that a nuclear-armed Iran could lead to World War Three.

A day later, Vice President Dick Cheney announced his own warning of "serious consequences" for Iran if it refused to abandon its nuclear activities.

The comments stirred fears of a possible U.S. military confrontation with Iran and helped send world oil prices soaring toward the $100 a barrel mark.

On Tuesday, some former intelligence officers said Bush and other top White House officials were probably briefed about the intelligence findings long before the NIE was published.

"I can't imagine that McConnell ... would tell the president about this and not tell him what the information actually said," remarked Flynt Leverett, a former member of Bush's National Security Council.

"I think they certainly played fast and loose with the facts," he said in an interview with CNN.

An NIE is intended to convey the consensus view of the 16 U.S. intelligence agencies on a topic of strategic concern to the United States. But former officials said the documents contain little new information.

"The president and his senior national security people get daily briefings, and the topics of those briefings are selected with an eye toward what is considered to be of most interest to current policy questions," said former senior intelligence analyst Paul Pillar.

Meanwhile, Democrats pounced on Bush with accusations that he had deliberately misrepresented the threat posed by Iran, just as they have said he exaggerated the threat posed by prewar Iraq.

"What's shocking today is that apparently he knew about this estimate a month or more before he made those statements," said U.S. Sen. Jack Reed, a Rhode Island Democrat.

"I don't think that shows a responsible use of intelligence."

U.S. Sen. Joseph Biden of Delaware, a Democratic presidential hopeful and chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said Bush had further undermined the United States' credibility around the world.

"The president's actions are doubly dangerous because they undercut the cooperation we need from other countries for dealing with the real problems Iran continues to pose," he said in a statement.

(Additional reporting by Susan Cornwell)

FILED UNDER: