ECB must do more to avert "cataclysmic" euro - Fitch

FRANKFURT Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:25pm GMT

A banner featuring a Euro coin is seen on the European Commission headquarters building in Brussels December 19, 2011. REUTERS/Yves Herman

A banner featuring a Euro coin is seen on the European Commission headquarters building in Brussels December 19, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Yves Herman

Related Video

Related Topics

FRANKFURT (Reuters) - The European Central Bank should ramp up its buying of troubled euro zone debt to support Italy and prevent a "cataclysmic" collapse of the euro, David Riley, the head of sovereign ratings for Fitch, said on Wednesday.

Speaking to investors as part of a European roadshow, Riley said a collapse of the euro would be disastrous for the global economy, and while it is not Fitch's baseline scenario, it could happen if Italy did not find a way out of its debt problems.

"The end of the euro would be cataclysmic. The euro is a reserve currency," Riley said. "What would that do in terms of financial and political stability?"

"It is hard to believe the euro will survive if Italy does not make it through," he said, adding that while many saw Italy as too politically and economically important to be allowed to fail, "one might also argue that it is too big to rescue."

The warning pushed the euro down toward a 16-month low versus the dollar.

Riley urged the European Central Bank to abandon its current reluctance to scaling up its purchases of troubled euro zone debt such as Italy's and drop its resistance to the bloc's bailout fund, the EFSF, borrowing directly from it.

"Can the euro be saved without more active engagement from the ECB? Quite frankly we think no," Riley said, adding that the bank had plenty of scope to expand its balance sheet without unleashing a wave of inflation across the euro zone.

"Why not have the ECB come out and say 'We are going to cap interest rates', say 'We are not going to allow interest rates to exceed 7 percent' or whatever level they see is the limit?.. Why not turn the EFSF into a bank so it can borrow from the ECB so it doesn't have to go to the market?"


Fitch has warned that the economic outlook for the euro zone has darkened further in recent months and has said there is a high chance it will downgrade Italy, Spain, Belgium, Ireland, Slovenia and Cyprus by one or two notches by the end of this month.

But unlike larger rival Standard & Poor's, which has all but Greece on a downgrade warning and said France risks a two notch cut, Fitch has said it does not expect to strip Paris of its triple-A status for this year at least.

Still, Riley cautioned the euro zone's second-biggest economy was in a precarious position as the crisis rumbled on.

"France is the weakest AAA country in the euro zone," he said, adding it had the additional burden of being the main country alongside Germany underpinning the euro zone's bailout fund.

Speaking to Reuters on the sidelines of the event, he also said that Germany's robust finances meant it would require a serious escalation of the euro zone's crisis to bring its triple A rating under threat.

Greece, meanwhile, remained a major threat for the euro zone.

Last year's move to force investors to take losses on their Greek bonds had destroyed the pre-crisis assumption that no euro zone country would default, while the current debate on Greece potentially leaving the euro was forcing investors to fundamentally rethink their view of the single currency.

"Arguably Greece leaving the euro could be the beginning of the end for the euro," Riley said. "Greece is still the joker in the pack. It still has the potential to plunge the euro zone into crisis."

But he reiterated that a euro split was not Fitch's current expectation. "We don't think Greece will leave the euro. The cost benefit analysis doesn't add up," Riley said.

(Editing by Hugh Lawson/Ruth Pitchford)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (2)
Wvandamme wrote:
Fitch should leave European policy to the elected European institutions and should start looking at itself and wonder. Why for instance did they give triple A status to these almost completely worthless US housing bonds?

Jan 11, 2012 4:27pm GMT  --  Report as abuse
margaretbowker wrote:
It’s good to see someone influential, like David Riley, joining those already saying that the ECB should cap Italian yields and say so. Italy is really trying and should be supported. Reduction in the ECB interest rate would also be good for assisting growth and if access for the EFSF to the ECB is not possible at present, what about the other direction and the ECB symbolically puts in some funding to encourage the increasing interest already being shown in funding the EFSF and the IMF.

Jan 11, 2012 5:55pm GMT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.