JPMorgan staff told go easy on Goldman's Muppetgate
LONDON/HONG KONG (Reuters) - Investment bank JPMorgan tried to contain damage to Wall Street's reputation on Thursday by telling staff not to try to profit from rival Goldman Sachs' embarrassment over a vitriolic resignation letter published in the New York Times.
Equity derivatives salesman Greg Smith caused a firestorm across the banking industry on Wednesday with the letter, published as an opinion column and calling Goldman (GS.N) a "toxic" place to work where senior staff saw clients as "muppets".
JPMorgan Chase & Co (JPM.N) Chief Executive Jamie Dimon warned employees in an internal memo not to seek advantage from Goldman's "alleged issues", imploring them focus on standards, not on the furore stirred by Smith in what media and bloggers have called "Muppetgate".
"I want to be clear that I don't want anyone here to seek advantage from a competitor's alleged issues or hearsay -- ever. It's not the way we do business," Dimon said in the memo, a copy of which was seen by Reuters.
Dimon's memo, awaiting Asia employees in their e-mail inboxes on Thursday morning, was sent to the bank's global operating committee and later forwarded to wider parts of JPMorgan, said sources who have seen the memo.
JPMorgan declined to comment.
London-based Smith, who had worked for Goldman for almost 12 years, called the bank a "toxic and destructive" place.
"It makes me ill how callously people talk about ripping their clients off," he said in the letter. "Over the last 12 months I have seen five different managing directors refer to their own clients as 'muppets'."
The storm goes to the heart of the reputational crisis in investment banking since public opinion started blaming the industry for its role in the 2008 banking crisis which brought the global financial system close to collapse.
"This could be just a disgruntled employee, but it comes at a time when the industry is not having a great time," said a senior mergers and acquisitions adviser. "Franchises can be affected by things like this," this person said.
Goldman said in its official response on Wednesday that the bank disagreed with the views expressed by Smith, "which we don't think reflect the way we run our business."
With the whole industry in a brighter spotlight since 2008, Goldman has faced a series of incidents that threaten to tarnish its image in particular.
Earlier this month accused of a conflict of interest for advising El Paso Corp on its sale to Kinder Morgan, in which the bank was a significant shareholder.
Sources at banks including Citi (C.N), Credit Suisse (CSGN.VX) and Nomura (9716.T) said they were not aware of any memo similar to Dimon's at their respective firms.
Insider: Short-term culture link.reuters.com/gyc27s
Felix Salmon: Smith's ballad reut.rs/znCmOx
Graphic: Recent woes link.reuters.com/dyc27s
Graphic: Stock timeline link.reuters.com/nuc27s
Graphic: Blankfein pay link.reuters.com/hys66s
Link: Smith op-ed piece: link.reuters.com/wyc27s</A1
Link: Goldman response: link.reuters.com/xyc27s
Link: Famous resignations: here
While Goldman Sachs is attempting to play down the Smith letter, the firm's shares fell 3.4 percent in trading in New York on Wednesday, and its impact has become a topic of discussion among its employees.
"It's definitely got people talking in the office," said an Asia-based Goldman Sachs trader who did not want to be named.
"It's amusing honestly because perceptions depend on the individual. For every one person who has something malicious to say about the company, you'll find 10 others who have a 180 (degrees different) view," the trader said.
Several former Goldman Sachs employees who worked at the company before its initial public offering said the firm's culture did change after it got listed, as Smith alleges, with bankers increasingly under the gun to boost profit.
"The culture definitely has changed since I was there," said property developer SOHO China CEO Zhang Xin, who worked at Goldman Sachs some 20 years ago and now is a client of the firm.
"Since the company went public there's this pressure on earnings," Xin said.
But two Goldman Sachs clients who work at different hedge funds both said that the criticisms that Smith levels at Goldman's corporate culture could equally apply to its rivals.
"If clients want to start awarding business to nicer, friendlier banks that would be great. But I don't think that is going to happen," said one industry insider.
(Reporting by Nishant Kumar, Clement Tan, Lawrence White and Alex Frew McMillan in HONG KONG, Emi Emoto in TOKYO, Narayanan Somasundaram in SYDNEY, Sumeet Chatterjee in MUMBAI and Victoria Howley in London.; Writing by Michael Flaherty and Douwe Miedema; Editing by Edmund Klamann and Andrew Callus)
- Tweet this
- Share this
- Digg this