In Spain, economic crisis fans Catalan separatism

MADRID Thu Sep 20, 2012 7:34am BST

Marchers wave Catalonian nationalist flags as they demonstrate during Catalan National Day in Barcelona September 11, 2012. REUTERS/Albert Gea

Marchers wave Catalonian nationalist flags as they demonstrate during Catalan National Day in Barcelona September 11, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Albert Gea

Related Topics

MADRID (Reuters) - Spain's economic crisis is exposing deep regional fault lines. Among Catalans on Barcelona's boulevards the talk is of independence, and Madrid is worried.

This week the king and prime minister called for national unity to get Spain through its worst downturn in decades, King Juan Carlos recalling the spirit that built a democracy after dictator Francisco Franco's death in 1975.

Popular momentum for independence has never been stronger in Catalonia, a wealthy region in north-eastern Spain that generates one fifth of the country's economic output and is home to 16 percent of Spaniards.

More than half of Catalans say they want a separate state, and hundreds of thousands marched in Barcelona last week - the biggest such show of separatist fervour.

Still, few see a rapid road to an independent Catalonia, a dream rooted in the Middle Ages when Barcelona was a Mediterranean trade centre with a parliament.

"It's going to be a difficult and long process ... For us to get it they would have to have a referendum, and they're not going to give us that," said Jose Maria Prats, a nurse who joined the march.

The upsurge in Catalan separatism is founded on a conviction that Madrid is draining the region financially.

The central government collects most taxation payments then redistributes them to Spain's 17 self-governing regions, which run their own schools and hospitals. Each year Catalans say they pay 16 billion euros more in taxes than the regional government spends.

"The crisis has shown that Spain's regional financing model does not work. There is no doubt we need to advance towards a federal system of taxation," said Jose Ignacio Conde-Ruiz, deputy head of think-tank FEDEA.

The flare-up in Catalonia has come at a difficult time for Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy who is struggling to bring Spain's deficit under control and resisting following Greece, Ireland and Portugal into an international bailout.

He has threatened to intervene in regions that cannot control their budgets. Catalonia is likely to miss its deficit target this year and has had to ask Madrid for a 5 billion euro bailout to meet its debt redemptions.


With an economy about the size of Portugal's, Catalonia houses global firms including toll road, telecoms and airport operator Abertis and healthcare group Grifols.

Children are schooled in Catalan and Spanish is treated as a foreign language in the home region of Joan Miro, Salvador Dali and Antoni Gaudi. Catalans banned bullfighting in a 2010 referendum highlighting their difference from the rest of Spain.

Such proud expressions of regional identity were suppressed during Franco's rule from 1939-1975, and the regions only won significant autonomy under the 1978 constitution that marked the country's return to democracy.

Catalan President Artur Mas, of the conservative Convergence and Union, or CiU, up until last week an advocate of autonomy but not of independence, has fallen into line with public opinion. He says he will work toward a referendum like the one Scotland may hold in 2014 on breaking its 305-year union with England.

"We went one way for 30 years and now there's a change in direction ... Catalonia needs instruments of state," he told Madrid's political and business elite at a forum last week.

In Madrid, economists scoff at the Catalan argument that they contribute more in taxes, saying any wealthy region of any country could say the same. Economists in Catalonia say the gap between the money flowing to Madrid and the money flowing back to the region is wider than in Scotland.

Even if it had to pay for its own military and diplomatic corps, the financial benefit to Catalonia would be equivalent to seven percent of its GDP, says Elisenda Paluzie, dean of the economics and business school at the University of Barcelona.

Mas and Rajoy are scheduled to meet on Thursday to discuss Mas's proposals to free Catalonia from the common tax regime.

Secession would complicate Catalonia's relationship with Europe. The European Union says an independent Catalonia seceded it would have to reapply for membership of the bloc.

(Additional reporting by Andres Gonzalez and Nigel Davies; Editing by Clare Kane and Janet McBride)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
CO2-Exhaler wrote:
It’s absolutely crucial for any of these would-be secessionists to obtain a definitive ruling on whether they would need to re-apply for membership of the EU. The Scots, for example, want to keep the pound, which in principle they could not do if a fresh application to join the EU was required (which they say is not the case). My instincts tell me that they are wrong (as the last paragraph of this article suggests) because there does not appear to be any logical or legal reason why in such circumstances they should be regarded as the successors in title of the “mother country” (how could they be while that country still exists?). The fact that they may say that they want to “adopt” all treaties and conventions is neither here nor there.

Sep 20, 2012 10:11am BST  --  Report as abuse
DrXavierV wrote:
Ms. Fiona Ortiz, what you say at the end about membership of the Eurpean Union is not true. There is not official answer from EU about this topic (as they don’t know it). It was some “personal” answers of some EU politicians. But, not an official answer. My opinion is that an independence of Catalonia will involve a direct membership of the EU. I can write a book about it, but here I only will point two reasons: (1) A separation of Catalonia from Spain will involve the creation of two NEW countries, i.e. the Catalonia Republic and the Castilian Kingdom (this is how I call the “new” Spain). So, just tell me, should be the Castilian Kingdom member of the EU? I think also “no” or also “yes”. The EU membership is with the current Spain, Spain without Catalonia is not anymore Spain. (2) Current Spain has adopted the euro as a currency. What will happen with Catalonia? It will have an own currency? Well let’s see the point here: Catalonia has a debt in euros. Who will pay this debt? I don’t think Madrid will pay it. Of course!, the Catalans will pay their debt. Now, if Catalonia creates a new currency, the Catalans will say that they will pay their debt when they can and as a not Eurozone country, it will have not restricted obligations to pay it (see what happened with the banks in Island). As the banks rules the world (included Europe), it’s clear to me that Catalonia (and the Castilian Kingdom) will be a member of the Eurozone from the first day of independence. And here my question: can be a member of the Eurozone out of the EU? I don’t think so.

Sep 20, 2012 12:47pm BST  --  Report as abuse
Raymond.Vermont wrote:

Catalonia could become like many a Latin American country and have a dollar aligned currency.

Sep 20, 2012 1:51pm BST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.