Argentine minister, UK MPs trade barbs in stormy meeting

LONDON Tue Feb 5, 2013 7:42pm GMT

1 of 2. Argentina's Foreign Minister Hector Timerman gestures as he arrives at the Houses of Parliament in London February 5, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Chris Helgren

Related Topics

LONDON (Reuters) - Argentina accused Britain on Tuesday of promoting Israeli-type settlement on occupied land in the Falkland Islands, while British parliamentarians said Buenos Aires was using "megaphone diplomacy" to assert its claims to the islands.

A bid to build confidence and bolster trade between Britain and Argentina in London's parliament descended into acrimony as British lawmakers and Argentinian Foreign Minister Hector Timerman traded barbs over the remote South Atlantic islands.

Britain and Argentina fought a 10-week war in 1982 over the Falklands, part of Britain's self-governing territories some 300 miles off Argentina's coast.

Buenos Aires calls the islands Las Malvinas, and has ramped up efforts to stake its claim to the territory as firms seek to tap oil and gas deposits around the islands.

Timerman, visiting Britain to further his country's claims to the Falklands, has declined to meet British Foreign Secretary William Hague to discuss the issue due to Britain's insistence that Falkland islanders also attend the meeting.

Argentina insists that the dispute is one between two states, and the views of the roughly 3,000 people living on the islands should be expressed through their own government, while Britain says the islanders have a right to self-determination.

Timerman dismissed a referendum on the islands' future planned in March, a vote widely expected to show the islanders want to remain British.

"The people living in the islands are British subjects, asking them if they want to be British is like asking (Israeli) settlers if they want to be Israeli or Palestinian. It makes no sense," Timerman said during a heated exchange.

Asked about his remarks to British media where he predicted Argentine ownership of the islands within two decades, Timerman said: "Through dialogue and support from all over the world we will be able to talk with the British and have a good result."

But he ruled out any future military move to seize the islands.

"No, of course, no never again, never," he told Reuters.

British parliamentarians accused Argentina of using "offensive" arguments and "megaphone diplomacy" in asserting its claims to the islands.

BANG THE DRUM

British lawmaker Chris Bryant labelled the comparison to Israeli settlers offensive, while Derek Twigg, who heads parliament's Falkland Islands group, retorted that the issue of self determination was "non-negotiable".

"The Falklands are not for Britain to give, or Argentina to take," he said.

Martin O'Neill, a member of parliament's upper chamber, accused Argentina of megaphone diplomacy and said Argentina never missed an opportunity "to bang the drum".

"It is one thing to come here and refuse to meet people. It's quite another thing to eschew any possibility of more subtle means," he told Timerman.

Both sides had started the meeting stressing historic ties and the benefits of boosting bilateral trade. Timerman had thanked Britain for its sacrifices during World War II.

The Argentine foreign minister was unfazed, and repeated his call for talks with Hague, but without the islanders.

"It is not true I don't want to hear the Falklanders' views. They have a foreign affairs minister who can tell me anything he wants about their views," he said, adding that he was ready for an open dialogue "right now".

"We can have a great future but there are issues in which we have to talk frankly and openly."

(Reporting by Mohammed Abbas; Editing by Jon Hemming)

FILED UNDER:
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (2)
CO2-Exhaler wrote:
The Argentinean government at the time of the last Falklands War was a military junta that had “disappeared” 30,000 of its own people, the fate of many of whom has never been traced. On the basis of this latest tantrum on the part of its Foreign Minister, the current government has no more concept of democracy than Galtieri’s, otherwise it would know that self-determination is one of the fundamental principles underpinning the UN Charter.

If the non-native American inhabitants of the United States decide one day that, all things considered, they really should up sticks and go back wherever they originally came from, the UK/Falkland Islands stance may be somewhat undermined, but in the meantime, I think they, and the UN Charter, are fairly secure.

Feb 05, 2013 9:37pm GMT  --  Report as abuse
CO2-Exhaler wrote:
The Argentinean government at the time of the last Falklands War was a military junta that had “disappeared” 30,000 of its own people, the fate of many of whom has never been traced. On the basis of this latest tantrum on the part of its Foreign Minister, the current government has no more concept of democracy than Galtieri’s, otherwise it would know that self-determination is one of the fundamental principles underpinning the UN Charter.

If the non-native American inhabitants of the United States decide one day that, all things considered, they really should up sticks and go back wherever they originally came from, the UK/Falkland Islands stance may be somewhat undermined, but in the meantime, I think they, and the UN Charter, are fairly secure.

Feb 05, 2013 9:37pm GMT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.