INTERVIEW-CIMB's Nazir faces headwinds after bold Asia expansion
KUALA LUMPUR Feb 18 (Reuters) - Nazir Razak, the chief executive of Malaysian bank CIMB, says his country is "at a crossroads" ahead of elections that his brother, the prime minister, must call within weeks. The same can be said of his bank.
A $3.7 billion Asia expansion by CIMB, aiming where others have failed to build a regional powerhouse by tapping fast-growing markets, is running into stiff headwinds from competition, rising costs and capital constraints.
Southeast Asia's fifth-largest bank affirmed its pan-Asian ambitions last year when it acquired the equity and corporate finance businesses in the region of Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc.
The combined operation is in its early days, but shareholders are getting impatient. CIMB stock, after climbing through much of last year, has pulled back in the wake of the $140 million deal and lost more than 20 percent since July 2011.
The majority state-owned bank also faces struggles at home and investor concerns over a failure in the past two years to deliver on the 18 to 20 percent return on equity (ROE) that the market had come to expect.
Nazir, 46, acknowledged in an interview with Reuters early this month the challenges that face Malaysia's No. 2 bank to make a profitable success of its forays beyond established footholds in Malaysia and Indonesia.
"We had the explosive growth - which was in many respects driven by low-hanging fruit," he said at the bank's Kuala Lumpur headquarters. "We feel that to have ROE expansion from here, we have to make some changes."
CIMB's ambitious plans risk repeating the disappointments at other domestic Asian banks such as Samsung Securities Co Ltd , Daiwa Securities Group Inc and Nomura Holdings Inc whose regional growth plans fell short.
Nazir said the RBS purchase was a calculated risk, but one that would allow CIMB to grab a bigger slice of fast-growing intra-Asian capital flows from global rivals.
"Asia needs a lot of capital but a lot of that capital is routed through London and New York, and through intermediaries," he said. "Asia is today stepping up to say: 'I can do some of that.' 'I can capitalise on that.'"
CIMB has a strong Malaysian investment banking franchise that capitalised on last year's flurry of domestic deals. It surged to third place in the 2012 Asia IPO bookrunner league table, according to Thomson Reuters, up from an also-ran 24th a year earlier, on $2.1 billion worth of deals. The rankings excluded Japan and Australia. CIMB's bookrunning credit last year was 38 percent bigger than rival Malayan Banking Bhd (Maybank), which was No. 6 in the rankings.
But that wave of IPOs, spurred in large part by a privatisation drive before the upcoming elections, is expected to recede dramatically this year, and CIMB has not attempted to build market share in the now-booming business of helping Asian companies issue dollar-denominated debt.
In the brokerage business, CIMB is building out an Asia-wide operation with a research team covering 1,000 companies. Brokerage build-outs, while a potential boon to sales and trading desks, are expensive to manage and - especially in Asia - face heavy competition from local and global players.
Nazir, architect of the bank's decade-long expansion from a domestic investment bank to a Southeast Asian giant, is unfazed. "Research will be a differentiator," he said.
He added that it was still too soon to judge the RBS acquisition. But some in the market already harbour doubts.
UBS said on Feb. 1 it slapped a "sell" rating on CIMB, seeing "limited scope for ROE expansion in the near term given the pressure on margins and higher overheads particularly, from the RBS acquisition".
The deal added less than 1 percent to CIMB's 45,000-strong workforce, but they were relatively high-wage positions. The RBS tie-up is already paying off, Nazir said.
"I see deals today - what we've won and will execute this year - that we would not have won as individual franchises," he told Reuters, citing the $416 million IPO of India's Religare Health Trust as an example.
Doubts like those at UBS notwithstanding, Nazir's regional strategy, which aims to reap 60 percent of net profit overseas by 2015 compared with 43 percent now, still has widespread backing from investors.
"Without him CIMB would have remained a very domestic-focused, pure investment bank," said Christopher Wong, senior investment manager at Aberdeen Asset Management Asia Ltd, one of the top 10 investors in CIMB.
"The jury is still out on some of the acquisitions, but even local competitors are trying to replicate this model."
With a Malaysia election due by April, the country's political winds are inevitably a topic for a CEO with family ties to the leadership. His father also once served as prime minister.
But Nazir, whose career at CIMB spans more than two decades, says the bank has steered clear of politics. He rejects the idea that a change in government would threaten its interests, or that his brother Najib Razak's position as finance minister and prime minister presents a potential conflict of interest.
"At the end of the day, whoever is in government will not want to do anything to undermine what is a very valuable investment for the Malaysian government," he said.
Politics aside, CIMB faces challenges on its home turf from heightened competition.
Maybank, the country's biggest bank, has gained at CIMB's expense in some areas of consumer and commercial banking, as it more aggressively chases a boom in consumer debt. CIMB makes 90 percent of its revenue from Malaysia and Indonesia.
Maybank shares, also bolstered by a higher dividend yield of 5.7 percent versus CIMB's 3.8 percent, climbed 7.6 percent over the course of 2011 and 2012, while CIMB lost nearly 12 percent.
CIMB has also struggled with costs as it revamps its consumer business and absorbs RBS-related expenses. Its cost-to-income ratio, at 56.6 percent in the third quarter of last year, was by far the highest among its Malaysian peers.
Some analysts said capital constraints could impede CIMB's efforts to expand and consolidate. They note it is aiming to raise its core equity tier 1 ratio - a measure of capital adequacy - to about 10 percent from an estimated 8 percent now to meet stricter Basel 3 requirements on capital from this year.
CIMB has proposed a dividend reinvestment scheme in the first half of 2013 to bolster its capital reserve, offering investors a choice of receiving shares instead of dividends. CIMB's recent sales of its insurance business will also help relieve it of extra capital requirements under Basel 3, Nazir said.
"I don't think we're capital constrained. We're comfortable with our capital levels." (Additional reporting by Saeed Azhar in Singapore and Lawrence White in Hong Kong; Editing by Michael Flaherty and Edmund Klamann)
- Tweet this
- Share this
- Digg this
- Rescuers scour sea for Malaysian jet lost in 'unprecedented mystery' |
- Exclusive: Malaysia plane probe narrows on mid-air disintegration - source
- Missing Malaysian jet may have disintegrated in mid-air - source |
- Merkel raps Putin as Russian forces tighten grip on Crimea |
- CORRECTED-UPDATE 4-Malaysia Airlines plane crashes in South China Sea with 239 people aboard - report