Independent Scotland would face currency problem - Osborne

LONDON Sun Apr 21, 2013 12:12am BST

Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, holds up his budget case for the cameras as he stands outside number 11 Downing Street, before delivering his budget to the House of Commons, in central London in this March 20, 2013 file photo. REUTERS/Stefan Wermuth/Files

Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, holds up his budget case for the cameras as he stands outside number 11 Downing Street, before delivering his budget to the House of Commons, in central London in this March 20, 2013 file photo.

Credit: Reuters/Stefan Wermuth/Files

Related Topics

LONDON (Reuters) - Chancellor George Osborne said on Sunday it would not be straightforward for an independent Scotland to keep the pound as its currency, as proposed by those campaigning for the country to break away from the United Kingdom next year.

The nation of five million will hold an independence referendum on September 18, 2014, at the instigation of the Scottish National Party (SNP), which runs the country's devolved government.

Pro-independence campaigners say Scotland would keep the pound, at least in the early years of independence, and could later hold a sovereign debate on whether to switch to its own currency.

But Osborne and his deputy Danny Alexander, who is Scottish, said in a joint article that monetary union would not work as well in "a disunited kingdom".

"The pound we share now works and it works well. Under independence all the alternatives are second best. So our question to the nationalists - are you really saying second best is good enough for Scotland?" the two men wrote.

As things stand, opinion polls suggest about 30 percent of Scottish voters favour independence while 50 percent would stick with the status quo, but those who want Scotland to remain part of the United Kingdom are not taking victory for granted.

The central government in London will publish on Tuesday a detailed analysis of the implications on currency of Scottish independence. The article by Osborne and Alexander sought to make the case against independence ahead of that report.

It said that if an independent Scotland kept the pound and thus had its monetary policy set by the Bank of England, that would amount to "handing over to what would become a foreign government key decisions over the Scottish economy".

"This is one of the big contradictions in their (the nationalists') whole economic approach," the article said.

"Campaigning to 'bring powers home' with one hand, while giving them away with the other ... It simply doesn't add up."

Osborne and Alexander accused SNP ministers of "tying themselves in knots" over the currency issue because in their heart of hearts they knew that economic and political union across the United Kingdom worked well.

In a speech delivered in Scotland last week, Alexander said the euro zone crisis had shown that combining monetary union with fiscal independence was challenging.

"While such arrangements can appear successful in a period of stability, they can lead to brutal readjustments in times of economic stress and uncertainty," he said.

Osborne's Conservative Party and Alexander's Liberal Democrats are both against independence but are not dominant forces in Scottish politics. The opposition Labour Party, traditionally a major force there, also opposes independence.

(Reporting by Estelle Shirbon; Editing by Stephen Powell)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (8)
LenRuscino wrote:
We live & die, go forward & back & go up & down by our word. Ask any Scot the value of an Englishman’s word & you will see how futile this media campaign is.

Burned into every Scottish brain is the fact that 80% of oil belongs to them!

Everything else is just a sideshow for our canny cousins.

The more the English protest at the planned independent Scotland the more sure the Scots will be to say goodbye to English rule!

Apr 21, 2013 7:10am BST  --  Report as abuse
Yoda_the_3rd wrote:
If the Scots do go for independence, it will be so funny when the oil runs out and they go bankrupt.

If the people of Orkney and Shetland go for separation from mainland Scotland then an independent will go belly up even sooner.

It will be so humiliating for the Scots when as a bankrupt independent country they come with the begging bowl asking for reunification. I hope we then say NO.

Apr 21, 2013 10:18am BST  --  Report as abuse
Raymond.Vermont wrote:
Scots should realise that any divorce ends up in lots of tears…

Under no circumstances should Scottish nationalists think that by splitting a working Union, they shall prosper from it.

LenRuscino writes about Scottish oil; well if Scottish nationalists think they can run an Independent Scotland off tax receipts that bring in all of 8-10 billion,in contributions to the UK Govt treasuries annual Expenditure bill of 690 billion pounds Sterling, then those nationalists truly are real Scotch eggs in their heads!

Apr 21, 2013 10:59am BST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.