EU must stop paying Gaza officials who don't work, auditors say

BRUSSELS Wed Dec 11, 2013 12:37pm GMT

Related Topics

BRUSSELS (Reuters) - The European Union should stop funding Palestinian civil servants in the Gaza Strip because money is going to officials who do not work, European auditors said on Wednesday.

As the biggest aid donor to the Palestinian territories, EU taxpayers pay a fifth of the salaries of teachers, doctors and bureaucrats in the small coastal territory, which has been governed by the Islamist group Hamas since 2007.

But following an investigation into how EU aid is being spent, the European Court of Auditors has found that large numbers of recipients are providing no public service.

The court did not have overall figures on the size of the problem. But in one spot check, 90 of the 125 employees at the National Audit Institute of Palestine said they did not work.

In another sample, 40 percent of civil servants were not working, EU auditor Hans Gustaf Wessberg, who led the inspections over the past 16 months, told a news conference.

"Our suggestion is to discontinue the programme for employees in Gaza," said Wessberg, saying the money could go to the West Bank instead. "The payment of civil servants who do not work does not meet one of (the EU's) main objectives to provide public services to the Palestinian people."

Wessberg denied EU money was going to former prisoners or militants and blamed the problem on the split in the Palestinian Authority between Hamas in Gaza and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas's Fatah party in the West Bank.

The auditors looked into around 1 billion euros ($1.38 billion) of spending in the Palestinian territories between 2008-2012.

Auditors could not establish what had happened to 90 million euros that was meant to pay fuel taxes and keep Gaza's only power plant running. Fuel shortages mean it has now ceased to serve nearly half the 1.8 million population.

Israel's on-off blockade of Gaza and Egypt's closure of around 1,200 tunnels that once linked the territory to the Sinai peninsula have choked off a large amount of economic activity.

The auditors' report raises questions about the oversight exercised by the European Commission, the EU executive, which is responsible for overseeing EU aid programmes.

But a Commission spokesman said many people were prevented from going to work in Gaza, referring to the fragile security situation in the strip, and needed financial support.

"If the Palestinian Authority is not paying these people, who is going to provide for them? If you have people running around without income, then of course, they are more prone to be taken by extremists," said Commission spokesman Peter Stano.

The report follows an EU audit published in June that found that a 1 billion euro package of support for Egypt from 2007 to 2013 had been mismanaged.

Over the past two decades, the EU has given 5.6 billion euros to the Palestinian territories. ($1 = 0.7261 euros)

(Reporting by Robin Emmott; editing by Luke Baker and Alistair Lyon)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
Parissa wrote:
It’s frightening to think that the EU is trying to judge the Palestinians with the same EU policies and standards, when the Palestinians are placed under sub human standards that will never be accepted or tolerated by any EU citizen.

When will the EU face the reality of the situation in Gaza?? the fact the 1.8 million trapped people are trying to exist under a MILITARY SIEGE by Israel, who control Gaza’s air, sea and land access and freely bomb them before every Israeli election, killing and maiming thousands of trapped people.

During the bombing, Israel purposely bombed the ONLY power station in the country, the only airport and spread phosphorate on the 800,000 children who were on their way to or from school that morning, the Israeli bombing started at 11.30AM and hit the UN school that was used as a shelter.

How can you expect a government official to fulfill their duty when Israel is illegally detaining thousands of people each and every year, under administrative detention, without any charge, completely disrupting any chance of human existence.

700 kids a year are woken up regularly in dawn raids, blind folded and taken away to be tortured, again without any charge or knowing what they’re there for, or how long, completely disrupting any chance of education.

Today Gaza kids are walking between the flooded sewers, not because of a natural disaster, or act of god, but because the rest of the world turned a blind eye to their existence

Dec 11, 2013 11:20pm GMT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.