French minister asks for appeal in virginity case

Mon Jun 2, 2008 7:48pm BST
 
Email | Print | | Single Page
[-] Text [+]

PARIS (Reuters) - France's Justice Minister Rachida Dati formally asked the public prosecutor's office on Monday to appeal a court ruling which annulled the union of two Muslims because the wife had lied about being a virgin.

Heated debate over French marriage laws erupted after the national press reported last week on the verdict, which was handed down by a court in the northern city of Lille in April.

Politicians, feminists and human rights activists have denounced the court's ruling as an affront to the legal equality of men and women and a violation of a woman's privacy.

"The annulment of a marriage by the court in Lille has sparked lively social debate. This private affair goes beyond the relations between two people and concerns all citizens of our country, especially women," the justice ministry said.

Dati has lodged a request for the public prosecutor's office to file an appeal against the court's judgement, the ministry said in a statement.

In an online interview broadcast by the Figaro newspaper, Prime Minister Francois Fillon said that while he understood the reason behind the judge's decision, the case merited an appeal.

"I think it is normal in such circumstances to request a new ruling," he said, adding that the country's highest court needed to spell out that the verdict does not set a precedent.

Concerns about traditional Muslim views creeping into secular French law has also shrouded debate over the case.

The husband's lawyer has denied that religion had anything to do with the verdict. The ruling hinged on a legal article saying an annulment could be sought if there was an error concerning "essential qualities" of one of the spouses. (Reporting by Laure Bretton and Thierry Leveque; editing by Brian Rohan and Ibon Villelabeitia)

 

Most Popular General News on Reuters UK

  • Articles
  • Videos
 A demonstrator pounds away the Berlin Wall as East Berlin border guards look on from above the Brandenburg Gate in this November 11, 1989 file photo. REUTERS/David Brauchli/File Photo
Berlin Wall anniversary

Twenty years after the Berlin Wall's fall, Reuters provides an in-depth, multimedia look at one of the 20th Century's defining moments.   Full Coverage