US CREDIT-Credit weakness may curtail any stock rally
By Karen Brettell and Anastasija Johnson
NEW YORK, July 14 (Reuters) - Corporate credit investors see no improvement in spreads over the near term, and until credit markets turn, stock markets may also be unlikely to escape the clutches of the bear.
A survey released on Monday by the International Association of Credit Portfolio Managers (IACPM) found that credit portfolio managers are expecting spreads to widen over the next three months, a change from the most recent survey taken in March when managers expected spreads to tighten.
This view contrasts with equity analysts who in the most recent Reuters survey last month said they view stock indexes as likely to rise through year-end, but end the year lower than where they began. For details, see [ID:nL09485810]
"Credit default swap spreads imply that credit concerns continue to remain elevated," said Gary Kelly, director of research at Tradition Asiel Securities in New York.
"Elevated credit risk implies limited access to capital, uncertainty towards underlying cashflows and potential for further credit-related losses," he said. And, "tight credit standards effectively cap equity market upside and create the potential for further downside."
Both stock market and credit derivative indexes have been battered over recent weeks on concerns that banks need to raise more capital to pay for losses from residential mortgage debt.
Banks have been curtailing their lending to companies and individuals alike as they dedicate capital to pay for mortgage losses.
Tradition's Kelly uses a proprietary credit index, based on moves in the most liquid credit default swaps, and compares this against benchmark equity indexes including the S&P 500.
"Allowing for an overly pessimistic CDS market, we believe the current CDS trend implies a reasonable trading level for the S&P 500 index at 1150-1200," he said. "Alternatively, CDS spreads across the market would need to narrow around 25 percent to support the current level of the S&P 500," Kelly said.
The benchmark U.S. investment grade credit derivative index has widened to 140 basis points, from a tight level of 86 basis points in early May, according to Markit Intraday.
The S&P 500 index has dipped to 1,228 from more than 1,400 in May.
Dave Klein, senior research analyst at Credit Derivatives Research, believes that credit and equity markets have moved back in line with each other, after the credit markets earlier this year greatly underperformed stocks.
Credit spreads weakened at a far greater pace than stocks, a move that was later viewed as being exaggerated, as investors fretted spread widening would trigger unwinds in some structured credit products. [ID:nN22585145]
Since the rescue of Bear Stearns in March, the credit and equity markets have come more in line, Klein said. As a general rule of thumb, however, credit markets anticipate weakness or improvement before stocks, "and the equities market confirms."
NEGATIVE SPREAD OUTLOOK
Expectations of further spread weakness then may not bode well for stocks.
The IACPM survey of its members, which includes portfolio managers at banks and other financial institutions in the U.S, Europe and Asia, showed a strong consensus that spreads are heading wider.
"Sentiment has clearly changed," said Som-lok Leung, executive director at IACPM. "The view on defaults over the last three quarters hasn't really changed, most people expect defaults are going to go up," he said.
Spreads, however, capture more than just default risks, he said.
"Spreads are a conglomeration of many things," he said. "Defaults, market risk premium, liquidity and all these other messier things are inherent in spreads."
Seventy-seven percent of respondents in IACPM's survey expect the U.S. investment grade credit derivative index to widen over the next three months, while 15 percent think it will end unchanged and 9 percent think it will narrow.
Sixty-seven percent of respondents also believe the European investment grade credit derivatives index will weaken, compared to 23 percent who think it will end unchanged and 9 percent who think it will improve. (Editing by James Dalgleish)
© Thomson Reuters 2009. All rights reserved. | Learn more about Thomson Reuters
