* Claims narrowed against ScotiaBank, HSBC
* Deutsche Bank settlement agreement expected soon
* Banks accused of suppressing, exploiting silver prices
(New throughout, adds comments, discussion of gold rigging
By Jonathan Stempel
NEW YORK, Oct 5 Silver investors may pursue a
lawsuit accusing two major banks of conspiring to fix prices and
exploit market distortions, affecting $30 billion traded each
year in the precious metal and related instruments, a federal
judge has ruled.
U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni in Manhattan rejected
efforts by Bank of Nova Scotia ("ScotiaBank") and HSBC
Holdings Plc to dismiss the lawsuit, in a decision made
public on Tuesday.
Caproni also dismissed UBS Group AG as a defendant,
saying there was nothing to show it manipulated prices.
Deutsche Bank AG settled related claims in April,
and the investors plan soon to seek preliminary approval of a
settlement, their lawyer Vincent Briganti, a partner at Lowey
Dannenberg Cohen & Hart, said on Wednesday. Terms
have not been disclosed.
ScotiaBank spokesman Rick Roth and Deutsche Bank spokeswoman
Amanda Williams declined to comment. HSBC had no immediate
comment. UBS spokeswoman Erica Chase said the Swiss bank is
pleased the court accepted its arguments.
Caproni also ruled in a separate decision that another group
of investors may pursue gold-rigging claims against ScotiaBank,
HSBC, Barclays Plc and Societe Generale.
In the silver case, investors accused Deutsche Bank,
ScotiaBank and HSBC of rigging prices through a secret daily
meeting called the Silver Fix.
They alleged that the conspiracy started by 1999, and
enabled the banks, including UBS through its alleged ability to
exploit the distortions, to pocket returns that could top 100
In her 61-page decision, Caproni said the investors
sufficiently, "albeit barely," alleged that Deutsche Bank, HSBC
and ScotiaBank violated U.S. antitrust law by conspiring
opportunistically to depress the Silver Fix from January 2007 to
Caproni gave the investors 14 days to amend their complaint,
including against UBS. Briganti said they plan to do so.
The case is In re: London Silver Fixing Ltd Antitrust
Litigation, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York,
(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Frances
Kerry and David Gregorio)