August 7, 2014 / 7:32 AM / 5 years ago

UPDATE 1-Guinea's Simandou iron ore trove: huge potential for the hugely patient

(Repeats with graphic link)

* Legal wrangles, delays mean no ore yet mined from huge deposit

* Price tag of development project estimated at $20 billion

* Needs 650 km of railway, 35 bridges, and 24 km of tunnels

* Rio Tinto, Vale, Israeli billionaire in legal rights wrangle (Adds Glencore comment on Rio plans)

By Saliou Samb

BEYLA, Guinea, Aug 5 (Reuters) - In a remote, southeastern corner of Guinea, the mist-shrouded Simandou mountain range rises above the lush forest. Buried under its green slopes lies some of the planet’s finest iron ore, a treasure long coveted by the world’s mining giants.

But any profit, for Guinea or the firms, will remain locked in the russet ground until an export outlet to the coast is cleared, a task that will involve building 650 kilometres (400 miles) of railway, 35 bridges, and 24 km of tunnels.

Coupled with the need for a new port to load the ore onto ships, the initial price tag would be around $20 billion, making it Africa’s biggest mining project ever, to be carried out in one of the continent’s most unstable and rundown nations.

“The logistical challenge is such that the whole project remains on hold until the infrastructure can be put in place to get the ore out,” said Madani Dia, a Guinean mining analyst.

Lack of adequate infrastructure - ports, roads and railways - to expand the trade and export of Africa’s mineral riches is one of the biggest brakes on the continent’s faster growth.

Global firms including Rio Tinto and Brazil’s Vale have for years been eying Simandou, and most recently miner and commodity trader Glencore has expressed interest in Guinea’s iron ore, a presentation obtained by Reuters shows.

Yet a mixture of political instability, protracted rows over rights and the eye-watering price tag for the overall project have meant actual production still remains a distant prospect.

A complex legal battle is playing out over the northern half of the huge deposit, with an Israeli billionaire, Vale, Rio Tinto and Guinea’s own government all battling to defend their positions after President Alpha Conde’s government revoked rights to the two northern concession blocks this year.

Few doubt Simandou’s huge potential. “Guinea’s current GDP is around $6.8 billion. To develop Simandou, up to $20 billion must be spent over the next five years, so the potential impact on the national economy is absolutely enormous,” said Tom Wilson, head of intelligence and analysis at consultancy Africa Practice.

But the risks are of similar proportions.

“It’s suicidal to invest in Simandou,” said a senior mining company executive who asked not to be named. He said that on top of the infrastructure challenge, Guinea’s volatile politics and business climate made it a big gamble.

“God knows how many times the government might change the mining code etc. ... It’s a very high-risk investment in a country where laws and rules are not stable,” the executive said. Since February, Guinea has also been fighting an outbreak of the deadly Ebola virus, which has killed more than 350 people there.

Complicating any investment proposal, Guinea also insists Simandou’s ore must be shipped from its own coast, rather than taking a shorter route via neighbouring Liberia.

In a sign of some progress after years of discussions and delays, Rio Tinto and partner Chinalco, the firms who control the southern two of Simandou’s four blocs, signed a deal with Guinea’s government in May outlining investment plans.

In Glencore’s presentation, however, it said Rio Tinto does not intend to move quickly to produce high volumes of iron ore from Africa before 2020, as its focus is on growth projects in Australia.

Rio Tinto, which declined to comment, only has the one iron ore project in Africa.

Although Simandou’s ore grade is viewed as one of the best among untapped reserves in the world, a sharp fall in prices of ore, as supply outstripped more moderate demand growth, has cooled interest for new iron ore projects. Shareholders are pressing mining firms to be much more careful about big risky greenfield investments.

Iron ore, the main ingredient in steel, now trades around $95 per tonne, down from a peak of almost $200 in 2011, and analysts expect prices to fall further in the next few years.


Far from the corporate offices and the courtroom battles, four-wheel-drive vehicles bounce down rutted tracks and up steep forested inclines en route to the colonial town of Beyla, beyond which Simandou emerges, its peak rising to 1,600 metres.

“In the 1990s, to reach the mountain you had to put your tent on your head and go by foot,” said Thierno Oumar Barry, a geologist at Rio Tinto.

When the rain falls, passenger busses and trucks ferrying goods sink deep into the mud. Locals say it is still often easier to walk, or travel by motorbike.

First identified as a potentially iron-rich zone over a century ago, Simandou has for decades been seen by mining firms as the jewel in the crown of West Africa’s vast mineral riches.

Small exploratory missions were carried out during French colonial rule and by Chinese geologists during the 1970s. Tests have revealed iron ore of up to 63 percent concentration.

By 1997, Rio Tinto had secured the rights to the four blocks that make up Simandou. However in 2008, the firm was stripped of the northern half, accused by Guinea’s late strongman leader Lansana Conte of not developing the project quickly enough.

The confiscated blocks were snapped up by Israeli billionaire Beny Steinmetz’s BSG Resources. Brazil’s Vale then bought a 51 percent stake of these in a $2.5 billion deal. It paid $500 million upfront and says it subsequently spent $700 million starting to develop the licence.

However, an investigation by U.S., Guinean and European authorities into how BSGR secured the concession has resulted in a former BSGR associate being jailed for corruption and Guinea stripping BSGR and Vale of the permit in April.

Barry, the Rio Tinto geologist, says the southern blocks 3 and 4, known as Ouleba and Pic de Fon, contain an estimated 2.4 billion tonnes of iron ore. Rio Tinto says the two blocks will produce 100 million tonnes a year at full production.

But Guinea’s stripping of BSGR’s northern section permits has triggered lawsuits by Rio Tinto, Vale and BSGR, adding to years of wrangling that have already delayed hopes of developing Simandou with one master plan, an approach experts say would be best.


As a result of the delays and legal disputes, not a single tonne of ore has yet been exported from Simandou. In Beyla, some 25 km (15 miles) to the east, the frustration is tangible.

“I have been in Beyla looking for work with Rio Tinto for five years,” Mamoudou Fofana, a heavy machinery specialist, told Reuters in the town, which turns to dust or mud with the seasons. “But it has come to nothing.”

At peak output, Rio Tinto said the project would create 4,000 direct jobs, 95 percent held by Guineans. Overall, 45,000 jobs would be added to the economy.

Hopefuls have been gathering for years in Beyla town and Moribadou, a collection of mud huts, where the population has jumped from 300 people in 1997 to 7,000 today.

Both places witnessed violent protests over the lack of jobs in 2011.

“Life is getting more and more difficult here,” said Djiba Camara, president of Moribadou’s youth association.

Camara said the cost of basic goods like rice had risen by nearly 70 percent and insecurity had spiked.

The Rio Tinto-Chinalco May agreement to develop Simandou does not give a precise timeframe, but a detailed feasibility study is due within a year, and in principle the first ore train is slated to depart by the end of 2018.

Once Simandou is producing, Guinea should benefit on many fronts. The investment in infrastructure will unlock access to the interior while bringing in $1 billion in revenues each year and eventually doubling the size of Guinea’s economy, according to documents on the project prepared by Rio Tinto.

Cece Noramou, a former government official now working on the project, says other firms are already eyeing opportunities. France’s Bouygues is interested in building tunnels, while General Electric is keen to supply locomotives.

Involvement of the World Bank’s private sector arm, IFC, which holds 5 percent in the Rio Tinto side of the deal, is intended to give confidence to investors.

Rolake Akinkugbe, vice president and head of natural resources at FBN Capital Nigeria, said funds for infrastructure were likely to come from investors ready to take the long-term view on Guinea, Asian export credit agencies watchful of demand for steel and other development institutions.

But optimism is taken with a pinch of salt in the surrounding towns.

“For 17 years, Rio Tinto have been making promises that never materialise,” said Mamadi Camara, manager of Villa Syli, Beyla’s only functioning hotel. (Additional reporting by Silvia Antonioli in London; Editing by David Lewis/Pascal Fletcher and Will Waterman)

0 : 0
  • narrow-browser-and-phone
  • medium-browser-and-portrait-tablet
  • landscape-tablet
  • medium-wide-browser
  • wide-browser-and-larger
  • medium-browser-and-landscape-tablet
  • medium-wide-browser-and-larger
  • above-phone
  • portrait-tablet-and-above
  • above-portrait-tablet
  • landscape-tablet-and-above
  • landscape-tablet-and-medium-wide-browser
  • portrait-tablet-and-below
  • landscape-tablet-and-below