World News

Ailing China dissident Liu seriously ill, lawyer says Beijing hastening his death

SHENYANG, China (Reuters) - A Chinese hospital treating sick dissident Liu Xiaobo offered a bleak prognosis on Monday, saying he is seriously ill, as a U.S. attorney who represents Liu accused Beijing of hastening his death by refusing to allow his transfer to a foreign hospital.

Pro-democracy activists stage a sit-in protest demanding the release of Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo, outside China's Liaison Office in Hong Kong, China July 10, 2017. REUTERS/Bobby Yip

Liu, 61, was jailed for 11 years in 2009 for “inciting subversion of state power” after he helped write a petition known as “Charter 08” calling for sweeping political reforms.

He was recently moved from jail to a hospital in the city of Shenyang to be treated for late-stage liver cancer.

The hospital said in a short statement Liu was also suffering from kidney problems, with an increasingly swollen stomach, partial intestinal obstruction and falling blood pressure, and that in his condition, it was not appropriate to treat him with radiotherapy.

His family had been informed, it said.

Questions have arisen over the possibility of Liu getting treatment abroad, and, if he wanted to go and was fit enough to go, if authorities would let him leave.

Calls have grown from rights groups and Western governments for China to allow Liu to travel with his wife, Liu Xia, to be treated overseas.

A German and U.S. doctor who visited Liu said on Sunday he could be moved abroad safely for treatment and he wanted to go to either Germany or the United States, but any move needed to happen soon.

They added that “additional options” may exist to treat him, including radiotherapy.

Slideshow ( 5 images )

Jared Genser, a U.S. attorney who represents Liu, urged the Chinese government to allow a transfer, noting that additional treatment abroad could extend Liu’s life for several weeks and that better palliative care would reduce his pain.

“By denying him treatments that would extend his life, the Chinese government is intentionally hastening his death,” Genser said in a statement late on Monday.

Asked on Monday at a daily news briefing whether China would allow Liu to go abroad for treatment, foreign ministry spokesman Geng Shuang said: “China hopes relevant countries will respect China’s sovereignty and will not use individual cases to interfere with China’s internal affairs.”

The government has said Liu is getting the best care possible and is being treated by renowned Chinese cancer experts.


Controversy also arose over video clips that appeared on YouTube, in which two foreign men, apparently the German and U.S. doctors, appeared to praise the quality of care Liu has received. Several video clips of Liu have appeared on YouTube, which is blocked in China, since his sickness came to light.

One clip showed Chinese doctors asking whether there was any better treatment possible for Liu, followed by a man, identified in text posted with the video as German doctor Markus Buechler, saying: “I don’t think we can do better in Germany.”

In another clip, Buechler was seen telling Liu’s wife that they considered their invitation a sign that Chinese doctors wanted to do their best to care for Liu.

The German embassy in Beijing said in a statement the recordings were made “against the expressed wishes of the German side, which were communicated in writing prior to the visit”.

“It seems that security organs are steering the process, not medical experts. This behaviour undermines trust in the authorities dealing with Mr Liu’s case, which is vital to ensure maximum success of his medical treatment,” the embassy said.

China has kept a tight control on information about Liu’s case and has imposed strict security at the hospital.

The 23rd floor of building number 1 of the First Hospital of China Medical University in Shenyang, where friends of Liu say he is being treated, has been sealed off, with access only for patients or family members.

Friends have confirmed that Liu’s family have been able to visit him.

A man in plain clothes who identified himself as working for the hospital told a Reuters journalist who went to the floor to leave. Asked if Liu was being treated there, the man, whose ID badge identified him as Teng Zhi, said: “Regardless of whether he is here or not, you cannot go in unless you are a family member.”

Police in plain clothes blocked a Reuters journalist from taking video of the hospital entrance. When asked if filming was not allowed because of Liu Xiaobo, they said: “Who’s that?”

The journalist was then escorted to what was described as a “media centre” in a nearby hotel where a man, who only gave his last name Zhang, said no one at the hospital was available for an interview.

Writing by Ben Blanchard; Additional reporting by Sue-Lin Wong in BEIJING and Andrea Shalal in Berlin; Editing by Robert Birsel and Catherine Evans