TOKYO (Reuters) - The Tokyo bourse said on Wednesday it was taking Toshiba Corp (6502.T) off a special watchlist, citing improved internal controls - a move that lessens but does not completely remove the risk of a delisting for the embattled conglomerate.
But offering a starkly different view of Toshiba’s accounting practices, proxy advisory firm ISS said it has recommended that Toshiba’s shareholders do not approve the firm’s earnings statements for the past financial year after a mixed review from its auditor.
Toshiba was placed on the bourse’s watchlist in the wake of a 2015 accounting scandal. It plunged into crisis again as of late last year after billions of dollars in liabilities emerged at its now bankrupt U.S. nuclear unit Westinghouse - problems that also raised fresh accounting concerns.
Aiming to plug the hole in its balance sheet, the Japanese company last month agreed to sell its chip unit to a consortium led by U.S. private equity firm Bain Capital for $18 billion (13.65 billion pounds), although the deal still needs to clear regulatory reviews and overcome legal challenges.
“The market had been expecting that the Tokyo bourse will remove Toshiba from the list and allow it to remain listed because the firm is too big to fail,” said Masayuki Otani, chief market analyst at Securities Japan.
Not only does the Japanese government see Toshiba’s chip business as vital to its national interests, the conglomerate’s domestic nuclear business is also key to the decommissioning of the Fukushima plants damaged in the 2011 earthquake and tsunami.
But the Tokyo stock exchange could come under further pressure to delist Toshiba if it is in negative net worth for a second year in a row at the end of March - a very real possibility as the chip deal may not gain regulatory clearance by then and it may struggle to raise funds by other means.
S&P Global Ratings said this month that there was “over a one-in-three chance that Toshiba will fail to receive sale proceeds and resolve its insolvency by March 31.”
If shareholders do not sign off on Toshiba’s earnings at a Oct. 24 extraordinary meeting as recommended by ISS, that could also imperil Toshiba’s ability to the recover from the crisis. Japanese shareholders, however, rarely reject proposals by management.
Auditor PricewaterhouseCoopers Aarata LLC gave Toshiba’s financial statements a “qualified opinion” that endorsed Toshiba’s finances despite some minor problems, but also made an “adverse” statement on Toshiba’s internal controls.
“It would be difficult to justify support for this resolution given the fact that the audit firm has rendered a qualified opinion, basically reflecting the auditor’s view that Toshiba’s financial statements are not accurate,” ISS said.
The controversy over Toshiba’s internal controls comes just as questions over corporate governance in Japan have taken the spotlight again, with a Kobe Steel Ltd (5406.T) crisis deepening on fresh revelations of data fabrication.
Separately, Toshiba said on Wednesday it would invest an additional 110 billion yen ($980 million) in the Fab 6 chip production line in Yokkaichi, central Japan, on top of a planned initial investment of 195 billion yen.
Toshiba also said it has recently asked Western Digital’s (WDC.O) SanDisk unit whether it intends to jointly participate in the investment.
Western Digital, Toshiba’s joint chip venture partner, objects to any sale without its consent, and is seeking an injunction to block the deal in the International Court of Arbitration.
Reporting by Makiko Yamazaki; Additional reporting by Chris Gallagher and Takahiko Wada; Editing by Edwina Gibbs